Modern architecture is undergoing a transformative shift, embracing free-form geometries powered by computational design. Exploring the synergy between mathematics and materials, freeform grid shells are reshaping the architectural landscape.
Free-form geometries are gaining traction in contemporary architecture. This trend is aided by the nascent discipline of computational design by which one can create complex geometry using a mathematical approach. CAAD (Computer Aided Architectural Design) software use two ways to generate free-form geometries – by traversing a generatrix over a directrix curve, also known as lofting or by fitting a NURBS (Non-Uniform Rational Basis Spline) surface through predefined control points.
While concrete, timber and aluminium are used for free-form construction, a grid shell consisting of a single-layer lattice in steel is the economical and aesthetically pleasing alternative. Such grid shells came into vogue in the 1960s and 1970s with the lead taken by Buckminster Fuller and Frei Otto who designed the geodesic Biosphere, Montreal in 1967 and free form grid shell Multihalle, Mannheim in 1975 respectively.
Standalone photo. Window cleaners at work at The Sage music and arts centre by the River Tyne in Gateshead.
Elastic grid shells
An elastic grid shell is a subset constructed from an initially flat grid without shear stiffness which is deformed into double curvature in situ. Over-sized joints or bendability of members ensures the deformability of such grid shells. Manneheim Multihalle is an example of an elastic grid shell. Such deployable grids are rarely used for permanent structures and sometimes as formwork for concrete shells.
Surface reticulation of grid shells can take many forms – triangular and quadrilateral being the most common. Grid shells display an arch-like behaviour, if they are not triangulated, irrespective of single or double curvature, while double curvature triangulated grid shells behave like double curvature continuum shells.
Challenges
Generating grids for free-form surfaces is a daunting task, especially if the following optimization criteria must be met :
Uniform member length:
This criterion minimises material wastage and optimises the load capacity of beams.
Planarity of panels:
Cutting a panel from a flat sheet is significantly less expensive than creating a complex doubly curved or warped panel. Triangular and planar quads known as scale-trans surfaces meet this criterion but rarely the following two criteria.
Torsion-free nodes:
For ease of manufacturing and construction, central planes of beams meeting at nodes coaxially are preferred. Such a mesh is known as a Planar Quad Conical Mesh.
Perfect nodes:
This is a subset of torsion-free nodes where both the top and bottom of straight beams meet nodes coaxially. Such a mesh is known as Edge Offset Mesh.
A simple assessment of these methods for geometrical generation and optimization of form is proposed in Table 1. One + sign means that only a partial answer to the problem is provided. The ++ signs mean that the problem is completely treated by the strategy. An x sign shows that a solution performs poorly for a given optimization goal. The xx sign indicates that a strategy is not suited for the considered optimisation task.
Table 1
Optimisation |
Angle repetition |
Length uniformity |
Panels planarity |
Node complexity |
Design freedom |
Triangular Mesh |
x |
++ |
++ |
xx |
++ |
Scale-trans Surfaces |
xx |
++ |
++ |
x |
xx |
PQ Conical Mesh |
+ |
+ |
++ |
+ |
+ |
Edge Offset Mesh |
+ |
x |
++ |
++ |
x |
[Ref: Romain Mesnil, Cyril Douthe, Olivier Baverel, Bruno Léger, Jean-François Caron. Isogonal moulding surfaces: A family of shapes for high node congruence in free-form structures. Automation in Construction, 2015, 59, pp.38–47]
Design considerations
-
Curved surfaces experience axial compression and tension
-
Flat or low-curvature surfaces are subjected to bending
-
Member, snap-through and global buckling need to be checked.
-
Roof cladding affects buckling and seismic performance
-
Member-ends and nodes should be capable of transferring bending moments
While gravity loads are well-defined for freeform structures, wind forces need to be determined either experimentally by wind tunnel tests or numerically by CFD (Computational Fluid Dynamic) analysis.
A large free-form grid shell may constitute hundreds of node types. One way of reducing node types is by clustering nodes with close enough angles at apices and fold-lines and designing nodes that allow slight variations in these angles. The decision regarding the manufacturing process largely depends on the repeatability of the item :
Batch Production
Large number of identical items
Computer Numerically Controlled (CNC) Production
Medium number of identical items
Additive Manufacturing (3d Printing) of Mould
Small number of identical items
Around the world
Here are some of the notable free-form grid shells from around the world :
The Great Court, British Museum, London:
Engineered by Buro Happold to a design by Foster + Partners, and built by Waagner-Biro. Covering 6,100 sq m, the 315 tonnes of glass that make up the roof are supported by a 478-tonne steel structure.
Sage Gateshead Concert Hall, England:
Designed by Foster+Partners, the roof covers three concert halls. The whole surface is made up of multiple arrière-voussure planar surfaces generated by a line that sits on two directing curved lines.
House for Hippopotamus, Berlin Zoo:
The surface was designed by Architect J. Gribl as two separate parabolic translational meshes that are connected with an anticlastic, non-uniform network. This central grid acts as a transition from one translational mesh to the other. The two domes are built entirely from 1.2 m long rods and planar glass panels.
Yas Hotel Gridshell, Abu Dhabi:
Designed by Asymptote Architect, Abu Dhabi’s five-star Yas Hotel is the first to span a Formula 1 racetrack. Two hotel buildings on either side of a bridge are linked by a curvilinear 217 m grid-shell structure that incorporates a striking illuminated steel and glass veil. Arup was involved in the structural design of the hotel bridge which spans 40 m and encloses 980 sq m of interior space on two levels.
Contributed by –Rudra Nevatia, Consulting Engineer
Very interesting info!Perfect just what I was searching for!Raise your business
Hello. impressive job. I did not imagine this. This is a impressive story. Thanks!
I am not very great with English but I get hold this real easygoing to translate.
I don’t think the title of your article matches the content lol. Just kidding, mainly because I had some doubts after reading the article.
Oh my goodness! an incredible article dude. Thanks However I am experiencing difficulty with ur rss . Don’t know why Unable to subscribe to it. Is there anybody getting identical rss drawback? Anybody who knows kindly respond. Thnkx
You should take part in a contest for one of the best blogs on the web. I will recommend this site!
Thank you for your sharing. I am worried that I lack creative ideas. It is your article that makes me full of hope. Thank you. But, I have a question, can you help me?
I have been checking out a few of your articles and i must say clever stuff. I will surely bookmark your site.
틱톡 美사업 매각 위해 중국 관세 조금 낮춰줄 https://bammin.info/수도
美USGS 미얀마 강진 사망자 1만명 넘을 확률 https://bammin.info/71퍼센트우려
이란 미 이스라엘 핵구실 공격시 핵무기 개발 본격화 https://bammin.info/위협
Real superb visual appeal on this web site, I’d value it 10 10.
머스크 300억원 퍼부었는데 ··위스콘신 대법관 선거 https://bammin.info/진보후보 승리
We absolutely love your blog and find almost all of your post’s to be what precisely I’m looking for. Do you offer guest writers to write content for you? I wouldn’t mind creating a post or elaborating on a lot of the subjects you write about here. Again, awesome blog!
머스크의 스페이스X 美국방부와 8조 위성발사 https://bammin.info/계약
What’s Happening i’m new to this, I stumbled upon this I have found It absolutely useful and it has helped me out loads. I hope to contribute & help other users like its helped me. Good job.
머스크 vs 나바로 관세 충돌에 포드 CEO는 https://cutypapers.com/머스크 편?
Your house is valueble for me. Thanks!…
EU 美철강관세 보복 90일 보류 트럼프 조치에 https://cutypapers.com/화답
네타냐후 아들 팔레스타인 독립 인정 추진 마크롱에 https://cutypapers.com/엿 먹어라
타국 전쟁에 한국군 끌려간다? 일본 멋대로 하나의 전장 제안 미국 https://cutypapers.com/반응은?
김치 먹어라 미국 전문가 뜻밖의 다이어트팁 https://cutypapers.com/이유는?
DHL 트럼프 관세전쟁에 800弗 이상 화물 美배송 일시중단 밤놀자주소
美 중국과 관세갈등 지속불가능 아주 가까운 미래에 완화 예상 밤놀자
美법원 트럼프 정부의 공립학교 DEI 정책 폐지 시도 제동 밤놀자최신주소
Thank you for sharing superb informations. Your web-site is very cool. I am impressed by the details that you’ve on this blog. It reveals how nicely you understand this subject. Bookmarked this web page, will come back for extra articles. You, my pal, ROCK! I found simply the info I already searched everywhere and just couldn’t come across. What a perfect website.
관세 늘면 소득세 줄거나 면제 트럼프 성난 민심 달래보지만 밤놀자주소
경험 부족한 등산객은 못 오르게 에베레스트 등반 자격 제한 추진밤놀자
아마존 창업자 베이조스 향후 1년간 6.6조원 규모 주식 매도 밤놀자
Yay google is my queen assisted me to find this great internet site! .
발표대로 관세 오르면 美연준 의장 파월 인플레 실업 위험 경고 밤놀자주소
https://pinupaz.top/# pin-up casino giris
secure checkout ED drugs: best price Cialis tablets – discreet shipping ED pills
파키스탄 인도 상대 군사작전 개시 핵 보유국간 확전 현실화 밤놀자
order Cialis online no prescription: generic tadalafil – buy generic Cialis online
buy modafinil online: modafinil legality – doctor-reviewed advice
safe online pharmacy: secure checkout Viagra – no doctor visit required
http://modafinilmd.store/# modafinil pharmacy
best price for Viagra: fast Viagra delivery – trusted Viagra suppliers
modafinil 2025: modafinil 2025 – purchase Modafinil without prescription
http://modafinilmd.store/# buy modafinil online
Viagra without prescription: best price for Viagra – fast Viagra delivery
http://zipgenericmd.com/# generic tadalafil
generic tadalafil: reliable online pharmacy Cialis – online Cialis pharmacy
http://zipgenericmd.com/# secure checkout ED drugs
safe online pharmacy: secure checkout Viagra – best price for Viagra
buy clomid no prescription: Clom Health – where can i get cheap clomid without prescription
PredniHealth: PredniHealth – PredniHealth
50 년간 관광지로 활용중인 美 최악 교도소 알카트라즈 하루 운영비 3배 달해 재개장 힘들듯 밤놀자주소
amoxicillin pharmacy price: how to buy amoxicillin online – Amo Health Care
베이비몬스터 트레저 중국 팝업 스토어 성황 밤놀자주소
I will right away grab your rss as I can’t find your e-mail subscription link or e-newsletter service. Do you have any? Kindly let me realize in order that I may just subscribe. Thanks.
이스라엘 美 트럼프 중동 순방 중 가자지구 공습 약 200명 사망 밤놀자
tadalafil generic headache nausea: does tadalafil lower blood pressure – can you purchase tadalafil in the us
buy cialis usa: cialis for sale online in canada – vidalista tadalafil reviews
no prescription female cialis: when will cialis become generic – tadalafil soft tabs
젤렌스키 美 협상서 멀어지면 안돼 주요국 고위급 회담 제안 밤놀자최신주소
지진난 것도 아닌데 650년 된 명나라 건축물 기와가 와르르 밤놀자주소
아이폰 미국서 만들면 대당 가격 480만원 된다밤놀자
ed meds by mail edmeds cheap ed pills online
https://biotpharm.shop/# buy antibiotics over the counter
역대 최대 규모 필리폰 인니 카리문섬 선박서 4000억대 밤놀자최신주소
antibiotic without presription: buy antibiotics online uk – buy antibiotics from canada
cheapest antibiotics BiotPharm buy antibiotics over the counter
get antibiotics without seeing a doctor: BiotPharm – buy antibiotics online
buy antibiotics from india: BiotPharm – Over the counter antibiotics pills
Ero Pharm Fast: Ero Pharm Fast – ed online meds
where can i get ed pills ed med online ed meds by mail
buy antibiotics for uti: BiotPharm – Over the counter antibiotics pills
buy ed pills online: Ero Pharm Fast – erectile dysfunction medicine online
https://biotpharm.shop/# antibiotic without presription
Over the counter antibiotics pills: buy antibiotics online – get antibiotics quickly
Over the counter antibiotics pills BiotPharm buy antibiotics for uti
buy antibiotics: buy antibiotics online – get antibiotics without seeing a doctor
https://pharmau24.com/# Pharm Au24
buy ed pills online buy erectile dysfunction treatment Ero Pharm Fast
PharmAu24: Discount pharmacy Australia – Buy medicine online Australia
Licensed online pharmacy AU: Pharm Au24 – Online medication store Australia
buy antibiotics for uti cheapest antibiotics cheapest antibiotics
각국 美관세 혼란에 신중 EU 무역협상 예정대로 진행 밤놀자최신주소